What a tarp is actually buying you
A tarp buys time. That is all it does. It keeps rain off an opening in the roof while somebody works out what is wrong underneath and gets the materials to fix it.
It does not seal anything. Water that gets under an edge runs down the deck the same as it would with no tarp at all. It does not reattach a lifted shingle, close a tear in the underlayment, or dry out wet decking. It sits on top of the damage and keeps more rain from landing on it.
How much time it buys depends on the weather it sees and how it was put on. We do not put a number of days on that, because nobody knows when the next storm is coming. What we can say is that the time is limited, and it starts running the day the tarp goes up.
What wind and sun do to a tarp
Wind is the fast problem. A tarp is a large flat sheet on a sloped surface, and every gust tries to get under it. Once an edge lifts, the wind fills it like a sail. The tarp pulls at its fasteners, slaps against the roof, and wears through where it rubs. One strong afternoon storm can do more damage than weeks of calm weather.
Sun is the slow problem. Most tarps are woven plastic, and Florida sun breaks that plastic down. It fades first, then stiffens, then starts to crack at the folds and around the grommets. You will not see it happen day to day. You will see it when the tarp tears in a place nobody touched.
Put the two together and you get the usual pattern. A tarp that looked fine through a stretch of calm weather fails in the first real wind, because the sun had already done the groundwork.
Why the battens matter more than the tarp
Battens are strips of lumber laid along the edges of the tarp. The tarp is wrapped around them and the strips are fastened through to the roof. That spreads the pull of the wind along the whole edge instead of loading a few points. The fasteners make holes of their own, which is one more reason a tarp is not meant to stay.
Without battens, a tarp is held by its grommets, by nails or screws punched straight through the plastic, or by sandbags and whatever else was within reach. Each of those holds at a point, and wind tears the tarp out around that point. A heavy tarp fastened badly will fail before a light one fastened well.
How it is laid matters too. Where the roof allows it, the top edge should run up over the ridge and down the other side, so water running down the slope goes over the tarp rather than under it. A tarp that stops partway up the roof lets water in behind its top edge, and that water goes straight to the damage it was meant to cover.
A heavy tarp fastened badly will fail before a light one fastened well.
Signs a tarp is failing
You can check most of this from the ground, and the ground is where you should stay. A tarped roof is a damaged roof, and a tarp is slippery when dry and worse when wet.
Look for edges that flap or lift in wind, a batten that has pulled loose or sits at an angle, and tears or holes, especially near fasteners. Look for water pooling in a sag. Pooled water is weight. It pulls at the fasteners and it finds any hole.
Look at the grommets if you can see them. Sun makes the plastic around them brittle, and they split out one at a time. A tarp with a row of torn grommets is held by fewer points than it started with.
Inside, the same rules apply as for any leak. A new stain, a damp patch that grows, or dripping in the attic during rain means water is getting past the tarp. Take a photograph and call.
Why a tarp is not a season-long fix
A tarp that looks intact is not the same as a tarp that is working. The plastic can be brittle under a clean-looking surface. Water can be running under one edge into the deck without showing on a ceiling yet. And the opening underneath is not getting better. Wet decking stays wet, and wet decking softens.
A tarp also does nothing for the rest of the roof. Whatever caused the damage may have loosened other areas the tarp is not over, and those will not show until they leak.
If there is an insurance claim, keep your photographs and the date the tarp went up. What the carrier decides about the damage, and about the time between the storm and the repair, is between you and your carrier. We do not know how they will decide, and we will not guess.
So the honest answer is the plain one. A tarp is a stopgap, not a repair. The permanent fix underneath still has to happen, and the sooner it does, the less the tarp's condition matters. Work performed by GenX Roofing LLC, Florida Certified Roofing Contractor, license CCC1333347.
