A roof is built for water that runs downhill
Shingles, flashing and valley metal all work on the same idea. Each piece overlaps the one below it, so water running down the slope always lands on top of the next layer and keeps going.
That works as long as the water is moving the way gravity sends it. Most rain does. It falls more or less straight down, hits the roof and runs off.
None of those laps are sealed against water moving the other way. Most of the time they do not have to be. The trouble starts when something pushes water sideways or up the slope.
What wind does to rain on a roof
In a squall line or a tropical system, rain is not falling. It is being thrown. Wind drives it sideways across the roof and up under the lower edge of shingles, into the gaps at step flashing, and past the laps at ridge vents and wall tie-ins.
A shingle with a weak or broken seal strip does not leak in ordinary rain. In a gust it lifts just enough for water to blow underneath, then lies back down. From the ground it looks fine afterward.
Pressure plays a part too. Wind pushes on the side of the roof facing it and pulls on the other side. Water gets forced through openings it would never find on its own.
A gap that never fills under vertical rain can flood under a gust.
Why it only leaks when the wind comes from one direction
Every weak spot on a roof faces somewhere. A step-flashing gap on the east side of a dormer only takes water when the wind is driving rain at that side. Rain from the west passes over it.
This is why people say it leaks in summer storms but not in fall rain, or only in storms that come in off the Gulf. The leak is not seasonal. The wind direction is.
Valleys behave the same way. Under normal rain a valley carries a lot of water, but it carries it downhill. A gust blowing across or up the valley can push that sheet of water sideways over the edge of the valley metal or under the shingles cut along it.
Sidewalls, chimneys, skylights and lanai tie-ins are the usual suspects. They are joints between a sloped roof and something vertical, and they only stay dry if the water stays on the right side of the flashing.
Sometimes is not the same as minor
A leak that shows up a few times a year feels like a small problem. It usually is not. It is an opening in the roof that happens to need a particular wind to show itself.
Water that gets in during those storms soaks the decking and sits in the insulation. Plywood that gets wet and dries over and over softens and delaminates, and the damage builds between the storms you notice.
The ceiling is the last place it shows. By the time a stain appears, the water has usually been reaching the deck for a while. We do not know how long on any given roof until someone looks.
Why it has to be traced during or right after the storm
On a calm, dry day the opening is closed. The shingle has settled back onto its course, the flashing looks seated, and there may be no fresh water anywhere. An inspection then can honestly find nothing.
During the storm or soon after it, the trail is still there. Wet decking, a damp truss, a drip line on the underside of the sheathing. Those lead uphill to where the water got in.
A hose test can recreate some of it, but only if it is aimed from the same direction the storm came from and worked from the bottom up. Spraying straight down on a roof that leaks in sideways rain will not reproduce anything.
So keep a record. Note which storms leaked and which did not, and which way the wind was blowing. Look in the attic with a light while it is still wet if you can do it safely, and call while the evidence is fresh.
